Mangino’s Pizzeria - New Castle (PA)

4 /5 J Melnik: Best variety of pizza in Lawrence and Mercer County. 3rd best chicken pastina I have ever had. Moms is the best, of course, and then Grandma from Mr. Pizza, but she only makes hers on Fridays. Highly recommend!

4 /5 Yetemar-Kenyell Cross: There’s nothing like the local Italian mainstay that a town is so grateful to have. I never heard of a “Dugout” before (I’m from outta town), but it beats a regular meatball sandwich to a tomatoey pulp. It was fabulous. Many choices of items here. Great service. Quality food. Consistency. I recommend this place.

3 /5 The Local Guide: The food is good. There is no doubt about that and the restaurant is clean. However, 4 slices of pizza, a pepperoni roll and a drink cost me $26. That is INSANE. Also, the woman who was asked to come wait on me due to the restaurant being busy had a rather unpleasant demeanor while I was being served, as if asking questions about the food and ordering food that I did not choose to have heated, was above her pay grade, she sighed and spoke to me in a disrespectful tone as if I was a bother.

5 /5 Shawn Myers: Visit at least once a month. Pizza is fantastic. The lasagna and meatballs are the best dish there. Well worth the trip for a great dinner.

5 /5 Jake Sager: These guys get a five star review for me because they take precautions. I ordered a pizza and then some pepperoni rolls with sauce. They wrapped their sauce in plastic wrap. On the way home, the whole bag fell onto the floor of my brand new truck. I initially was very upset until I walked around and saw that the cups of sauce were wrapped in plastic wrap and completely safe. Thank you for saving my vehicle