MP Coney Island - New Castle (PA)

5 /5 Kim’s Adventures & More: It’s been awhile since I’ve been to or had this incredible chili dog sauce that they make & it’s better than I can recall. They certainly have perfected it. But, they also grill up tasty & flavorful hotdogs which are then only complimented by that sauce. My Dad claims it by far the best in all the nearby counties & he just may be right. I wonder how many agree?

5 /5 Gregg Dudash: These are one of my favorite foods ever. I will drive from Columbus Ohio to get a few dozen. Will freeze them and reheat. I will buy a quart of chilli to separate and freeze for future use. I was born in New Castle and have been there so many times over the years to visit and always stop and get some. Love the old school diner like booths. I always have good service too.

1 /5 Unhappy customer: Name should be PHONEY ISLAND. Fool me once, shame on you. With "Coney Island" in the name, I expected a real all beef hot dog. We had to ask if they were beef hot dogs, and were told no.. Sadly we already paid or I would have cancelled the order... Its basically bologna.. Imagine our surprise when we received toddler sized microwaved or boiled hot dogs in mini buns. Everything about the hot dog was barely room temperature. A 10 year old can make a better dog in their microwave at home... The fries were decent. I got a chili dog, I was looking for the chili, all I got was brown liquid, that was flavorless and cold. This restaurant is an embarrassment... Do not bother. Waste of money. You can make a real beef hot dog on the grill or even in a pan on the stove at home that is way better than this.

5 /5 Mike Wincko: It was our first time there today. I got 2 dogs with chili, mustard and onion. They were delicious!! We also got cheese fries. There were a ton of fries with a mountain of liquid cheese! Also... super friendly service. Since it was our first time there, I had questions. Everyone behind the counter was smiling and happy to answer anything we asked. I got two containers or their chili sauce to go so i can try to duplicate the dogs at home but rest assured we will be back! ❤️❤️

4 /5 Josey Custer: I feel like the interior is a little dated. But I feel like this is where you go for that original hot dog shoppe Margie dog. The cashiers are always awesome. Welcoming but not over the top. Always have someone wiping down tables and keeping things clean. Love it.