Martys Pizzeria - Nanticoke (PA)

2 /5 James Garro: Food was so good and surprisingly enough? The salad that came with and before the food was great and Im honestly not used to that. Worthwhile food. I hope I get to try the pizza soon! Update 10/18/2025 The second time Ive walked into this place and I got nothing but a silent stare and a face like I didnt belong. The food wasnt nearly as good as the first time. The spaghetti and meatballs were awful simply because those meatballs could be used in case the Flyers lose a hockey puck they were so dry and flavorless but on top of it all, instead of giving a proper greeting with a smile instead of awkwardness or good service in general, Im met with a weird look over and over and a $22 bill I shouldve never paid for such mediocre service and food today and no, I wont be back. Get your people to learn their jobs.

5 /5 John Ziomek: I had asked linguine Alfredo topped with Cajun Haddock,the chef Alex Accommodated my request and was perfect a must try .The salad with it was large and fresh, try it with crumbled blue cheese and the house wing sauce as your dressing.I will definitely order this again.Thank you.

5 /5 Eric McDermott: First time trying Martys in Nanticoke. The pizza was amazing. The crust made the pizza top notch. The bites were good too.

2 /5 Jill Morris: We ordered out so we didnt get to deal with much of the service. Its Friday night and I know that means its crunch time in a restaurant Ive worked in MANY before. We ordered 4 things technically 3. We decided on 2 crab stuffed mushrooms, that tasted like there crab has been sitting out for a week, a chicken bacon ranch pizza with broccoli, which wasnt bad for the free extra toppings we didnt ask for like a couple uncooked onions and half backed tomatoes but I guess they were used becuase they ran out of baconor something, and mild wing bites, that were just a bit dry. Crab stuffed mushrooms should not be almost 10 bucks when your getting something like that back. Weve been here not that long ago and raved about the food. I really hope you didnt get a new chef, and we were very disappointed.