Four Star Pizza - Oil City (PA)

1 /5 KO: Ordered two steak and cheese subs with mushrooms & a large pizza and this is what I got. There is more lettuce and mushrooms than steak. I don’t even know if there is steak on this sub. Very disappointing especially since I spent almost $50 on my order. Next time I’ll just make it at home.

1 /5 Caitlinnn: NEVER AGAIN! Last night around 9:30 I ordered 2 12inch subs & App Sampler. Pretty simple, grilled chicken with lettuce tomato onion & Extra Mayo easy right? NOT FOR FOUR STAR OIL CITY! My husbands sub didn’t even have mayo ON IT! It was all over the aluminum foil, I mean like just slapped on! Plus the deep fried appetizers were SO SOGGY! I called today for them to make it right & the gentleman told me because I didn’t call last night, even tho it was closed by time we got our food & went to eat it, there was “nothing he can do” Even though I have photos, my receipt & STILL HAVE THE NASTY SUB! $30 later & only got to eat one sub! Horrible, HORRIBLE SERVICE!!!

4 /5 Rick Rarer: Best pizza around IMO, wish it was a little less expensive, or they had good coupons like they used to back in the 80s & 90s

5 /5 Isaac Perea: Guys over there are awesome friendly and over well welcoming made my food delicious correct and definitely my choice to get great pizza, wings, and sandwiches

5 /5 Odin Tillgren: Amazing local pizza, good crust, well topped. Bacon and pineapple is my favorite