pennsylvania Date: 05-15-2026

Highly Recommended 8 Dinner Restaurants Near Hermitage, Pennsylvania

Planning dinner tonight? Check out highly recommended restaurants in [Hermitage] known for quality food and memorable dining experiences.

RestaurantsAddressPrice_level
1Tops Buffet2980 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148Inexpensive
2Hickory Bar & Grille1645 N Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148Moderate
3Red Lobster3370 Shenango Valley Fwy, Hermitage, PA 16148Moderate
4Combine Brothers2376 S Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148Moderate
5Eatn Park2270 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148Inexpensive
6Bob Evans115 S Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148Moderate
7El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant & Cantina3101 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148Moderate
8La Isla Mexican Restaurant1800 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148Inexpensive

1.Tops Buffet

Address: 2980 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Tops Buffet

(984) user ratings total:

Kayla Bonzo Tops has been around for well over 10 years. I have never been dissatisfied with anything I’ve eaten here! It’s conveniently located in the plaza by the movie theater. The food is always good and this establishment is family run. The same woman has been here for years and it makes a difference when you walk into a restaurant years later and you are still recognized. The food is delicious and hot, the options are plenty, and the prices are still reasonable. I love it here and will always recommend Tops when someone asks. Perfect place for dinner before your movie or even on the go!
5 /5
=

2.Hickory Bar & Grille

Address: 1645 N Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Hickory Bar & Grille

(2138) user ratings total:

Ms Alhadi Hello to all my gluten-free and Celiac friends, I was in PA visiting my family and we stopped at hickory grill and bar. The atmosphere was amazing. Our our sweet was Brandy, and I told her I have a gluten allergy and she told me that the items that I can eat and made sure to tell the cooks and write a note. I had the steak, the coleslaw and the grilled shrimp and everything was delicious. I will definitely go there again and try different options. They do have some of the options as gluten free in the menu. Just let them know that you have an allergy and enjoy!
5 /5
=

3.Red Lobster

Address: 3370 Shenango Valley Fwy, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Red Lobster

(1468) user ratings total:

Shannon Houk We come here every year when we are Christmas shopping and also my birthday( it’s a family tradition for the past 10 years ) . Every time we come this place is amazing. The food and the service. However today was the cherry. Our server was phenomenal and our food was the best. We just wanted to say thank you. It’s hard to find service like we had and food that is made that well. Our server was Kelly R. She is amazing! My husbands filet was cooked to a perfect rare , my fish and chips was excellent. My 10 year old tried clam chowder today for the first time and each bite he made a “mmmmm” sound. He loved it. Thanks to all involved in an excellent experience
5 /5
=

4.Combine Brothers

Address: 2376 S Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Combine Brothers

(1463) user ratings total:

L Kristie Everything they have is homemade from the noodles down to the sauces. Portion sizes are very large and and great as leftovers.
5 /5
=

5.Eatn Park

Address: 2270 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Eatn Park

(1445) user ratings total:

Chaz Thompson Maya is so awesome!! Salad Bar is GOLD - plenty of seating and nice tasting food.. I put blue cheese crumbles on the cole slaw by accident.. I know eww.. but it was honestly the best combo of flavor Ive had to date - will forever put those two together.
5 /5
=

6.Bob Evans

Address: 115 S Hermitage Rd, Hermitage, PA 16148

images Bob Evans

(1429) user ratings total:

Anthony Vanpelt We had 6 in our party for a late lunch and teams meeting with 2 that couldnt attend. Waitress worked with us and service was great. Much appreciated!
5 /5
=

7.El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant & Cantina

Address: 3101 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148

images El Vallarta Mexican Restaurant & Cantina

(1251) user ratings total:

Rob R On a long road trip, we stopped at this exit as it had the most chain restaurant options, but we saw this Mexican restaurant and gave it a try. It did NOT disappoint. Super clean, vibrantly decorated, and appointed with unique ‘green’ walls imitating plants and vegetation. The bathroom was cleaner than mine at home. The food was fresh, hot, and delicious. Great service and the food came out quickly. Great find. Highly recommend, it’s always a good idea to skip the chain restaurants - especially when there’s a great option like this.
5 /5
=

8.La Isla Mexican Restaurant

Address: 1800 E State St, Hermitage, PA 16148

images La Isla Mexican Restaurant

(1074) user ratings total:

N M I was taken here by some family friends and it was my first time. We ordered Beef Steak Tacos, Jesus special, Chicken Fajita. I can’t tell you which of these was the best. They were all so amazingly super super delicious. Loved every bite I was taking if these. Sadly tummies have a limit or else I could have eaten this awesome food non-stop. To add to the already enjoyable food the owner and the server were so very friendly and kept a tab in us on a timely basis to ensure everything was perfect and so it was including the ambience. Would definitely go there many more times and highly recommend everyone to pay them a visit.
5 /5
=