2 /5 MO: I’m curious as to what they added to the seafood Newburgh to make it orange. It definitely wasn’t old bay which probably would have been an improvement. Wasn’t expecting salad shrimp in it and I did expect more than a sliver of a scallop, if it was scallop at all. The rice was just gross. Chicken Parmesan sandwich is a chicken patty instead of a fried chicken breast, as one expects with chicken parm sandwiches. They toasted the bread but somehow the bread was floppy and soggy instead of crisp? How does that happen? Chef was asking the waitress questions about cooking when it’s his job to cook and hers to serve. Can’t imagine that’s a good sign. I’m not sure if this place has good reviews bc old folks have low standards and the place was full of seniors or if York is just a bad place for food and folks here just don’t know it. I haven’t had a good meal in this town yet. The bathroom was spotless and they were kind enough to take the sandwich off the bill as it was inedible. I did appreciate that. Also our waitress was very kind so they get stars for that but I’d rather have bad service with amazing food than vice versa.
