Pagleys Pasta & More - New Castle (PA)

5 /5 Daniel Zappola: Everything I’ve had there has been excellent, but I think the cheese raviolis are my favorite. They are over stuffed and so good. I hope one day they start selling them frozen so I can take them home and put my own sauce on them that would be excellent. Although I really do like their sauce also.

5 /5 Norm Goings: The food was absolutely amazing. Everything we had was superb and priced very competitively. The service was fine but pretty slow, it wasnt our servers fault, she was great but there only seemed to be two servers in the whole place during Saturday dinner service. The atmosphere... you dont go here for the ambience you go for the food. We will definitely be back.

5 /5 Joe Funkhouser: This place is amazing you couldnt ask for a better Italian restaurant. My 8-year-old absolutely loves the calamari. She gets it anytime and every time we go there. This is one of my mom and pops favorite places to go to eat after church. The staff are always amazing

1 /5 Alexis Scott: Haven’t been to Pagley’s in about a year since the last time I came our server was SO slow and was no where to be found. After we paid, came outside to see him smoking in the parking lot. Guess that’s where he was the whole time. Came back today to try again and had the same guy. Hostess was wonderful but the male server with the ponytail only came to our table to get our order (after the other servers had to find him) and bring our food and check. Slow, unpleasant and was again no where to be found when we needed things (even though the restaurant was almost empty). Would’ve loved to get dessert but he just brought the check. I had to ask another server to charge our card cause he took forever to come back to the table.

5 /5 Izabella Browning: Food was delicious! Atmosphere was very empty and dated. Only $60 for three people with multiple plates of food! Amazingly huge and delicious portions! Waitress name was Taylor! Excellent as well! Definitely recommend