2 /5 Luis Rosado: I did a Google search for “Steaks on Hamilton St” since I was picking up food from another restaurant on Hamilton St as well but I wanted a steak for myself. Max & Butter’s shows up on the search so I check their menu and settled on “The Frenchie” which is an 8oz ribeye (ordered mine medium) with a side of diced potatoes in some tangy cheesy sauce and boy was I disappointed with the steak. I should’ve opened the carry out container before leaving to check but unfortunately I didn’t.
As soon as I got home and opened the box I was so disappointed and upset with what I saw, the steak had a weak almost non existent sear on the outside and was absolutely bland, devoid of any seasoning for taste. I took one bite and said “there’s no way I would have served this to a customer”, one bite and I had to throw the rest of the steak away. The side of potatoes was “okay”.
I’m not one to write reviews and much less negative ones at that but the steaks I cook at home seem gourmet steakhouse level compared to what I got served. My first time ordering from there and unfortunately will be my last due to the terrible 1st impression they left. I truly hope the establishment can improve upon their steak offerings in the future, maybe this was just a one-off but any true steak lover would not return after being served the steak I was. Good luck and hopefully the restaurant can take this as constructive criticism and honest feedback to improve upon the product that comes out of their kitchen.
