Guadalajara Mexican Restaurant - York (PA)

5 /5 Markus Aguilar: This restaurant was a great dining experience, the restaurant itself was beautiful with very nice decor, seating, and menus. They made the price of dishes clear and described all of them. Our waitress was very sweet, she kept up on our dishes and drinks, answered any questions we had, and made our time there easy while still paying attention to the other customers. The food was very very good. It was definitely fresh and made to order. We will absolutely be eating here again!

2 /5 BIG HOSS: this used to be such a solid spot. good atmosphere, great service, decent food (not the most authentic, but delicious and available in every configuration you can imagine). about fall 2025 i had a bad meal here, with no regulars working the floor, and chalked it up to a bad day. went in recently with friends and was shocked. my food was near inedible. it didn’t arrive how i ordered it, nor am i even sure it was WHAT i ordered. i’ve had this particular dish thousands of times in mexican restaurants from new york city to san francisco to tijuana and back and i’ve never had it served up chewy in a thick sauce. even the salsa was bad—it used to be thick and spicy, but this time it was weirdly sweet and watery. the server tried, but spoke neither ingles nor español with any fluency. and the music was not appropriate for a restaurante mexicano… atmospheric AI slop that could not be identified. anyway, confirmed that there’s new management in the place. i didn’t even see a single mexican working, and i guarantee no cocinero made my dinner. i will not be back, please beware—if you enjoyed GUADALAJARA, this is not the same place (their facebook page is even called guadalajara 2.0). oh and they raised every single price on the menu.

1 /5 Samantha Lippy: Not a great experience. There was a huge hair in my drink. When brought to their attention there was no apology, just came back to ask how the food was. The food tasted good. However, I asked to sub the sweet potato fries with rice, which I got, but they didn’t give me the beans that should’ve went with my meal. The music was loud. The waiter was not personable. The seat cushions need some TLC. Not an establishment that I will recommend or go back to.

5 /5 Megan Block: This is our go to place. Leaving this review after my son and I came here on New Years Eve for dinner. They were swamped, party of 12 in the middle of the dining room and every booth full. We still got prompt service and delicious food from their friendly staff!