Old Corner Hotel - Williamsport (PA)

5 /5 Cody Bost: I was in the area and had a wonderful dinner at the Old Corner. The dining room is beautiful and was surprisingly quiet at 7:30 on a Friday evening, granted this was my first time, but the bar area was packed. The focaccia was amazingly fresh and I can’t rave enough about the pickled peppers served as part of the dipping ensemble. Amazing and unlike any bread dipping mix that I’ve ever experienced. The clams casino was prepared very well and worthy of trying, but the clams themselves had a mediocre flavor. This place isn’t exactly on the beachfront, so I can’t fault them for the clam stock. For the main course I chose the filet mignon seared in a bacon-balsamic redux, medium, with mashed potatoes. The steak was a little beyond medium, but everything about it was absolutely perfect; so tender and fantastically flavorful. If I was still in town tonight, I might do it all over again.

5 /5 JUDY GALANTINO: Had called ahead 2 see if a game was on the telly. It was. Dinner & cocktails were yummy. The nachos r really good. & side of mashers also yum. Service was good. Old school vibe. Def b back.

1 /5 Zachary T Fortin: I’ve been a regular at many local spots for years, and The Old Corner is the one I’ve wanted to support the most. Sadly, the owner’s consistently unpleasant demeanor has made that difficult. The environment feels tense, and the staff often seem unhappy or disengaged. It’s frustrating to watch a place with so much promise undermined by poor treatment and negative energy.

1 /5 Michael Prostka: This place was out of steak and salmon during our trip but didn’t tell us until after we ordered drinks and appetizers. Service really went down hill after we expressed our disappointment in being out of the main selling points of the menu. The outdoor patio was a cool but the live music was entirely too loud to enjoy dinner. The musician was however awesome overall. Drinks were fantastic all around.

4 /5 Sherry G: This review is a bit of a mixed bag. I had a fine experience with the hostess, who seated me quickly on the patio. However, there were some notable drawbacks. The bugs on the wall and a persistent yellow jacket were a definite problem. My server, while not unfriendly, was not particularly warm either. Though they brought my food and drink in a timely fashion, it was difficult to hear the specials over the ambient noise, so I took a chance on the grouper. The food, including the grouper and my drink, was good. This is why it was so frustrating that the meal felt severely overpriced for the amount of food on the plate. Ultimately, the great taste didnt outweigh the average value and other issues.