Colony Pub & Grille - Erie (PA)

4 /5 Scott Shaffer: Food was great , server was great. Only small issue was we had a meeting/dinner with decent size party and the chairs were so close you had no room to move and was very very warm in there (though we were near the fireplace). Other then that no concerns.

5 /5 Diane Pappas: Had a couple with us who indicated several places in Erie who had perch that it didn’t really taste like perch. We assured them colony had great perch and they got the sandwich. They loved it. I got the perch dinner. I never said anything but the owner came over and was not happy it was overdone. So he sent it back to the kitchen to have it done correctly. The attention to making it a good experience was greatly appreciated. It’s hard to find this type of good service. Highly recommend.

4 /5 Edward Kowalski: Pros- Easy parking, outdoor seating option in warm weather, indoor cozy fireplace, classy inside, but not stuffy. Great menu selection with decent portion sizes. Nice selection of specials offered nightly. Warm bread served with dinners. Roasted vegetables served with my entrée were decadently delicious (a mix of grilled squash & peppers). Casey, our server was very helpful always with a smile. . Cons- Low ceiling painted black makes for a claustrophobic feeling. Salad dressing and butter in plastic cups (low class). Interesting because side dinner sauce came out in nice metal ramekin. Dinner salad comes with cherry tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, iceberg, and other lettuce leaves, but also pre-packaged croutons. Apparently, I got the end of the bag because my salad was covered in crumbs. Salmon was overcooked, but edible, no complaints, however, I specifically asked what roasted vegetables came with the salmon and was told, but only a garnish of kale & carrot curls were on the plate. Once alerted, our pleasant server, Casey, quickly brought out the side of veggies. Desserts were offered, but unfortunately tasted as if made off-site and stored in a freezer for a while and were slightly stale. Thats a bad way to end a meal. Live music is a nice touch, but unfortunately, it was too loud for conversation at the table. . I would definitely return because the food is very good.But I just wanted to give a fair and balanced review.

4 /5 Erica Hess: My first time here, (there are two entrances)*faces the building the side (right) is the entrance to their dining room (left) is entrance to the bar. First off they are very welcoming and start to serve you water. We ordered soft pretzels, and baked potato skins no tomato and they served sour cream on the side it cute little solo cup containers. My boyfriend got the chicken tenders, I got the chicken parm, it was really juicy a breaded. They put grapes on the plate as well. Our waitress was so nice I would definitely go back again especially just to sit in her section.

5 /5 Mary Savelli: Our family had dinner there and we all were able to find something to eat, even though 4 of us have dietary restrictions. While the food was good, the service was great.