BJs Market Street Tavern & Oyster Bar - Selinsgrove (PA)

4 /5 Miss Val: We came here for dinner on a Monday in April. I had been here one other time a few years ago but don’t remember what I had. We sat at the bar. The bartender, Hannah I think, was friendly and personable. God love her there were a couple obnoxious men at the other end of the bar and she was pleasant to them and apologized to everyone else in the bar after they left. We had a couple drinks and shared the calamari and crab cakes. The calamari had some spicy peppers in it and I really liked it but if you aren’t in to spicy maybe see if they can hold the peppers. The crab cakes were good as well. We did each have a clams casino and that was not my favorite thing but I am used to smaller more well cooked clams with no casino. The atmosphere, despite the obnoxious couple of dudes, was easygoing and casual. Prices were good. Parking was in the street no meters. We had a good time and enjoyed the meals.

1 /5 Nancy Mensch: New Years Eve 6pm reservations for 6 got seated upstairs and finally ordered at 6:30 and food never came till 8:15pm and steak was to be medium rare and was burned completely dry and baked potato was to have extra sour cream and had a smear instead and ran out of corn bread now lets get to the burned up crab cake that was inedible and the baked potato for that meal was mashed potato so guess what they ran out of baked potatoes and didnt tell us not that it matters mine was inedible and also ran out of deserts not that I would have ordered one and bought $50 gift certificates where you get free bongo dip and they changed it to $25 gift certificate get free bongo so I told the hostess at the door I want the rest of my certificates and said she couldnt do that!!!! Manager finally came to our table at 8:45pm and made everything right for us so shout out to the bar manager and our sweet waitress that was also upset at what her job presented her that night.I will be back but bongo and smokehouse salad is what is safe to order!!

5 /5 D S: Great small town bar with excellent service. Visited on a Saturday afternoon shortly after opening. The bar side has a really cool vibe with a bar booths and a standing bar. We had a group of 12 and we were all able to hang together with the layout. The bartender was super friendly and helpful. Good selection of draft beers, wine and mixed drinks. Lots of variety of oysters and clams. We had a few appetizers that were very tasty but portions are on the small side. Great spot, can’t wait to return

1 /5 Chris C: Live somewhat local and this was my first time here. Arrived for a 7pm reservation. Seated and ordered by 7:10. Didn’t get food until almost 8:30. Wasn’t offered any explanation or that sort of thing for the wait. Numerous tables around us were chatting and I could tell experiencing the same. As for the food… ordered the “award winning” Classic Burger and let’s just say I’d rather have ate McDonald’s. Dry, cold, and just downright awful. Girlfriend’s scallops were tiny and the pasta was cold. For almost $70 I could have went to Texas Roadhouse right up the road and got a much better dinner for half the price. Needless to say I’d give 0 stars if I could… we won’t be back.

5 /5 Patrick Zerbe: This place is a classic! Fanciest version of contemporary Pennsylvania fair, but also modern interesting takes. Definitely the fanciest seafood Ive had in this part of the world. Their appetizers are fantastic. They also cook their steaks to perfection. They will also include anchovies on their Caesar salads which I really enjoy. If you dont want to have a banquet, their bar is fantastic! They have a lot of great stuff on tap and they use name brand alcohol for all of their mixed drinks. I didnt see any cheap mixers behind the bar. The bar tender was knowlegable and friendly. She was also happy to modify anything you asked her for. Over all I Loved this place. Only thing that was a little questionable was the sort of outside cold bathroom. Thats kind of a trademark of this part of the world though.